preschool,Montessori,teaching approach,traditional teaching,Romanticism
ParentingPreschooler

The 3 Teaching Approaches and Finding the Right One for your Preschooler

Which one is best suited your child?

preschooler

As the new year marks a new beginning for everyone, it is also a signal to parents of preschool-aged children that it is time to search for an answer to that big question on their minds: where do I enroll my child?

With the increasing changes in our society, family dynamics have been placed under pressure. Some children have both parents investing their time in economic responsibilities that merit stability for their own families. This results to young children being left under the supervision of their immediate families, a caregiver, or childcare institutions. In relation to the latter, De los Angeles-Bautista, as cited in Franco’s 2009 thesis entitled A Model of Home and School Partnership of Progressive Preschools in the Philippines, mentions that Filipinos place great emphasis on completion of higher education, and therefore, a major parental concern is sending their children to good schools.

In De los Angeles-Bautista’s article on Early Childhood Care and Education in the Philippines (2004), she explained that preschool education was expected to put children ahead, which assures parents that their children are capable of facing the first challenges in their school life.

A study on the state of preschool education in the Philippines by Natividad Santos in 1990 revealed that education is a Filipino family concern as it is highly connected to one’s status. Santos explains further that families are willing to contribute and to sacrifice in order that they can invest in one’s education. The Philippine society’s emphasis on education is exemplified by the continued proliferation of schools in the country. Therefore, there is also an increase in preschool enrollment.

At present, the numbers continue to grow. This supports an emerging trend for education to begin during the earliest years. Dr. Evalyn Hizon, a professor from the University of the Philippines-Diliman’s Department of Family Life and Child Development, explains that there are three educational ideologies or streams of thought according to Kohlberg and Mayer (1972). “There are different approaches to education, and these are: Progressivism, Cultural transmission (traditional) and Romanticism,” Hizon says.

watch now

"Traditional" is the typical preschool classroom in the Philippines. Dr. Hizon explains that we are all familiar with the traditional approach because of our direct experience with it during our schooling. She says that, “this is characterized by teacher-directed lessons especially in grade school and high school levels of both public and private schools except for some”. According to Dr. Hizon, students are encouraged to learn more in a short period of time where there is more memorization and less interaction. She adds that, “lessons come from the interests of the teacher where the emphasis is on the academics-writing, reading and arithmetic.

Angela Dee, 28, opted to send her only son to a traditional preschool. She says that she considered a variety of factors when she chose this particular school such as the school environment, student–to-teacher ratio, and the tuition fee. She explains further that what she liked about her son’s school was that, “ … hindi stressed ang bata kasi yung subject nila exact lang for toddlers. Math, Language, Reading and Writing lang. And may playtime pa din na very educational.” She adds that the teachers were hands-on and they allowed enough pacing for every lesson. Angela identifies the many benefits that Luis gained from the preschool such as being “more interactive, friendly, sociable, and he learned how to take care of himself whenever I’m not with him”.

[previous|page|next]

The Romanticist approach is similar to the Montessori program, according to Dr. Hizon. She notes that this is self-paced because it is according to the child’s stage of maturation. “Play is encouraged and it is process-oriented. Activities are paced and the child starts from the most simple and moves on to the more complex, so the child cannot work on something as he pleases,” Dr. Hizon explains. She mentions that this espouses a more individualized instruction, where “a child can work alone because materials are self-correcting. He can discover his mistakes if the material doesn’t fit to its desired size, then he can check and change”.

Richie Ramos-Pilares, a lawyer and mother of a two-year old, narrates how she did her own research on the different types of preschools. Her daughter Ally attended the free trial classes and, after seeing Ally’s interest with the materials and activities presented in the school, she decided to send her child to a school espousing the Montessori approach. According to Richie, “she is excited to get up in the morning to go to school and feels said when it is time to go home. For me, it is very important that my daughter is not forced into doing anything.” Richie continues to explain her knowledge about the program: “the teacher gives her students materials to work on using materials that enrich a child’s vocabulary, develop gross and fine motor skills and encourage logical thinking.”

When asked about what she loves most about her child’s school, Richie notes that the interaction between the younger and older children is valuable since the children are encouraged to help each other and to bring out the best in each other. Richie adds that, “Ally is very orderly and she also knows how to pack away her toys. Her vocabulary is also amazing. She knows how to count from 1 to 10 and not just rote counting. She also knows how to respect other life forms. She never picks flowers; instead, she just touches them.”

According to Dr. Hizon, the Progressive approach "is child-centered because it emphasizes the socio-emotional and mental or cognitive development of the child." She adds that “it focuses on the process rather than the product. This means that in this approach, it is more important to see how the child draws a picture rather than judging the end-product.” Hizon explains that the progressive school’s curriculum uses a variety of rich learning experiences that suit the interests and needs of each student. She adds that the curriculum aims to develop the whole child through activities that will foster hands-on experiences like field trips and dramatic play that will express their imagination and emotions through the materials. Lastly, Hizon mentions that learning is featured through play because this is the natural work and interest of children.

Rochie Yoro, mother of two boys, sends her toddler to a progressive school. She says, “we decided on our son’s school based on feedback of graduates and proximity to our house and workplace.” When she was asked about her opinion on her son’s development, “Gabo’s creative side has been unleashed. He enjoys dancing to music with actions he learns from school. It is easier to teach him to do certain chores such as washing his hands, and he fixes his toys without too much prodding. He isn’t afraid of other kids and adults. He responds to his classmates and teachers when called.”

[previous|page|next]

Dr. Hizon advices parents to consider the following when choosing schools for their children:
1. Your child’s style of learning.
She says, “Parents should not insist on where the child should go, but rather, to know the child’s learning style to make her/him happy”.

2. Refrain from imitating other parents’ wishes.
Dr. Hizon explains that parents should not simply follow where their friends’ children are also enrolled.

3. Parents should make the choice not based on their convenience but on what is good for their child.
Dr. Hizon says, “Each child is unique and therefore, she has her own distinct characteristics from the other children.”

4. Know your child first and foremost - from head to toe, if possible.

It is very important that you think about it several times when deciding where to send your child for preschool education. Ask yourself the following questions and let your reflection guide you to your personal decision. Such questions are the following:
1. What are my goals for my child?
2. What are my child’s interests, hobbies and unique characteristics?

In relation to this, parents should be proactive in this decision-making process. They should research about the different programs by reading books, surfing websites and gaining feedback from other parents. They should visit these schools together with their child so they can directly interview the school administrators and let the child explore the environment in each potential school. Lastly, constantly communicate with your child by seeking his or her opinion towards his or her school preference.

Bredekamp and Copple (2009) emphasized in the book Developmentally Appropriate Practice in Early Childhood Programs the value of developmentally-appropriate practices in every childhood program. This means that “all teaching practices should be appropriate to children’s age and developmental status, attuned to them as unique individuals, and responsive to the social and cultural contexts in which they live” (p.xii).  In addition to this, curriculum composed of both child-guided and teacher-guided learning experiences are crucial to a child’s development and learning. Bredekamp and Copple noted that “curriculum is very important, but what the teacher does is paramount” (p.xiii).

It is a child’s every right to be educated. Furthermore, it is every parent’s role to provide his or her child quality education. Studies show that the earliest years in a child’s life are the formative years. When we see children happy and actively exploring the world around them through meaningful learning experiences, this becomes the “truest measure of success as early childhood educators” (Bredekamp & Copple, p.x). Thus, it is every parent’s responsibility to look for a reliable support provider that will nurture his or her child with high quality early childhood experiences during this special time of his or her life.

References:
Franco, P. (2009). A Model of Home and School Partnership of progressive preschools in the Philippines. Unpublished master’s thesis. Pacific Oaks College, California
Bredekamp, S., & Copple, C. (Eds.). (2009). Developmentally Appropriate Practice in Early Childhood Programs. Washington, DC: National Association for the Education of Young Children
De los Angeles-Bautista, F. (2004). Early Childhood Care and Education in the Philippines. In Early Childhood Counts, Evans Judith 2000.
Kohlberg, L., & Mayer, R. (1972). Development as the Aim of Education. Harvard Educational Review. 42(4), 449-496
Santos, N. (1990). State of the art in preschool education in the Philippines: Its implication for teacher education. Diliman, Quezon City: University of the Philippines College of Education, U.P. Office of Research Coordination.

Photo from flickr creative commons

Trending in Summit Network

lorem ipsum

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod
Read more
lorem ipsum

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod
Read more
lorem ipsum

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod
Read more
Close