This awards and graduation season, the topic of awarding students has stirred a range of opinions among parents, as reflected in discussions on social media platforms and parenting communities. It began with a post on X (formerly Twitter) that raised questions about the increasing number of students receiving honors and rewards, which seem to dilute their significance. The post reads:
“It’s graduation season. Pero bakit parang lahat ng mga bata may honor at awards? Sorry hindi naman sa hindi masaya para sa kanila, pero naalala ko lang ang hirap mag-honor dati at pag may honor ka parang nakakabilib talaga. Musta naman yun 2/3 ng class may honor? Tapos kulelat tayo sa PISA?”
We shared this insight to the 100,000-strong Smart Parenting Village and we received a wide array of responses from the parent members.
Positive views on the current awarding system
For most parents, the increase in student awardees is a positive, seeing it for its motivational benefits and inclusivity. They believe that acknowledging more students can foster a love for learning and promote a supportive educational environment.
One parent stressed the motivational impact of recognizing more students, saying, “Recognizing more students is a great way to motivate them to work harder and celebrate their successes. In the past, only a few top students received recognition. And as someone who was always an ‘achiever,’ I know the value of hard work. Pero, I think these new rules that acknowledge more students are better. By broadening the scope of recognition, we encourage more students to strive for excellence. This inclusivity not only motivates them but also creates a more positive and supportive school environment. Let’s celebrate all achievements, big and small, and inspire our students to reach their full potential.”
Another parent appreciated the inclusivity and equity of the current system, noting, “I like the present awards system compared sa before, no competition (especially among parents na gusto anak nila ang top 1 palagi), thus no pressure sa students rin. Also, recognized ang kanya-kanyang strengths nila sa special awards.” This highlights how the new system does away with unhealthy competition among parents and students, and allows for better recognition of each student’s strengths.
One parent pointed out how awards can motivate students and how today’s generation is making the most of the resources available to them, “Yes, napansin din ng asawa ko yan. Pero I think, mas matatalino ang bata ngayon kasi more advanced. Minsan yung pa nila dapat matutunan/malaman eh nalalaman na nila dahil napapanood sa social media. Pero nakakatuwa naman na maraming may awards–kasi for me nakakasipag kapag may award.
Another acknowledged the original post’s concern about educational quality based on international rankings, saying, “Gets ko yung concern about falling behind in international academic rankings despite giving many awards. However, recognizing more students for their academic achievements can help develop a love for learning, which is essential for long-term success.”
Moreover, some parents emphasized that the current system gives value to encouraging effort and building self-esteem. One parent shared, “Thankfully, the school my LO is in does this and you’ll see that kids and parents are appreciative and happy. My hubs and I also don’t put any pressure on him and his schooling, as long as he’s happy and excited to learn,” illustrating the importance of building a supportive environment fostered by recognizing more students.
Concerns about the current system
Despite the positive aspects, some parents expressed concerns that the increased number of awards may diminish their value and fail to address deeper educational issues in the country.
One parent expressed his concern that awards might lose their significance if too many students receive them, commenting, “Minsan parang pamigay na yung dating ng award. Don’t take it negatively, what I mean is nawawalan ng exclusivity and prestige yung awards since sa average nalang nag-focus and may rounding off pa na nagaganap.”
Balancing recognition and pressure
A lot of parents feel that balance is needed in recognizing students’ efforts and maintaining meaningful standards. Moreover, parents emphasize the importance of not overloading children with pressure and ensuring that awards genuinely reflect significant achievements.
A parent highlighted the need for balanced recognition, stating, “Recognition can be a double-edged sword, in the right amounts it can be a motivation pero pag sobra naman, it’s also not good. They can become slaves to external validation, balance is key. Biggest validation will come from us parents. If we acknowledge the child’s effort the whole year, malaki impact nun sa kanila.”
Another parent echoed the insight on the importance of parental support and encouragement, noting, “We always recognize their efforts and small achievements, and we encourage them to strive more. There is always room for failures and improvements. Instead of pressuring them, we encourage them that it is okay to fail and try again.” This reflects a nurturing approach that values effort and resilience.
Comparisons on past and present systems
Several parents also couldn’t help but compare the current with past awarding systems, with some appreciating the exclusivity afforded by the old system while also acknowledging the benefits of the new, inclusive approach.
Reflecting on the old system, a parent shared, “During our time, we had a valedictorian and salutatorian. Pros: Prestigious and exclusive ang awarding. Kilala mo talaga kung sino ang mga nangunguna sa klase. Nabibigyan ng focus yung batang nagsikap para manguna.”
The same parent then compared it the to the current system, saying, “Pros: Madami na ang nabibigyan ng pagkilala na nakakamotivate sa mga bata para lalo sila magsipag at magsumikap. Hindi na din mahigpit kasi kahit na may below 85 na grade, pwede padin makasama sa honors,” suggesting that the new system is more inclusive and motivational.
Advantages of technology and modern learning
Parents also recognize the significant impact of technology and modern educational resources on students’ learning capabilities and achievements.
One parent observed how today’s digital capabilities affected this generation of students, stating, “Mas madami nang matatalinong bata ngayon. They have the means and technology to begin with, compared sa mga bata before. Dati kasi we need to go to the library pa to gather information. Ngayon one click nalang lalabas na sa net.”
Another parent noted the early exposure to complex concepts, sharing, “Knowledge will always progress, the next generation will always be smarter than the previous one. Kahit ako nagugulat na sa lessons ng mga bagets now may introduction of integers na ang grade 3, while ako HS ko na siya nalaman.” Highlighting how today’s curriculum introduces advanced topics earlier than in the past.
This ongoing discussion highlights how complex the issue is. While many appreciate the inclusivity and motivational aspects of the current awarding system, others’ concern about value of the awards and broader implications for educational quality are also valid. The key challenge seems to lie in striking the right balance between recognizing achievements and maintaining rigorous standards.
The good thing is that it is evident that many parents recognize the importance of encouraging effort and resilience, recognizing diverse strengths, and providing balanced support to their children, more than rewards.
Read here for parents’ insights on graduation money garland.